Socialism vs. Communism: Differences between Communism vs. Socialism

Socialism vs. communism are two political and economic ideologies that both aim to address issues of inequality and seek to reduce the economic disparities often associated with capitalistic systems. These terms are often used interchangeably, even though there exist big differences between them.

Socialism vs. Communism: The Main Differences

Key Takeaways

  • Socialism focuses on the equal distribution of wealth and a state-managed economy; communism aims for a classless society and common ownership.
  • The principles of socialism can be realized within democratic frameworks; communism typically involves abolishing the current governing structures.
  • While sharing similarities, socialism and communism differ in their views on private property, governance, and the pathway to achieving their ideals.

Socialism vs. CommunismPin

Socialism vs. Communism: Definition and Origins

Defining Socialism

Socialism emerged as a response to the inequalities triggered by the Industrial Revolution. We typically understand socialism as a socio-economic system where the resources and means of production are owned, controlled, or regulated by the community as a whole. This can manifest in a variety of ways, but a common thread is the emphasis on social welfare and reducing economic disparities.

Defining Communism

Communism, in contrast, is a more radical form of socialism. Karl Marx, a key figure in defining communism, envisioned it as a classless, stateless society stemming from socialism but taking the principles to their most extreme conclusion. It’s marked by the absence of private property where all goods are owned collectively, and ideally, everyone contributes and receives according to their needs.

Real-World Examples

Socialist Countries

Norway: Often cited as an example of ‘social democracy’, which blends a capitalist economy with a comprehensive welfare state and robust public sector. The Norwegian government controls key sectors like healthcare, education, and transportation, though private enterprise also thrives.

Sweden: Like Norway, Sweden operates under social democracy. The country provides extensive social benefits to its citizens, including universal healthcare and a generous social security system, but maintains a market-based economy.

Communist States

The Soviet Union: From 1922 to 1991, it was the most prominent example of a communist state based on Marxist-Leninist principles. The state owned all means of production, and the government planned the economy.

The People’s Republic of China: Founded in 1949, China remains a communist state under the leadership of the Communist Party, although it has significantly reformed its economy since the late 20th century, allowing for limited market mechanisms and private enterprise within its socialist market economy.

The Differences

The first difference is in the philosophy of these two systems. COMMUNISM suggests that everyone in society contributes and works according to their ability, and gets back everything according to their needs. SOCIALISM, on the other hand, suggests that contribution is made by everyone according to their ability but they get back according to the size of their contribution.

So, in a socialistic system, profits are distributed depending on the results of every individual’s work, while in a communistic system, everyone has free access to all the goods that the community has to offer.

In communism, there is no government because everything is owned collectively by every member of society. However, in a socialistic system, there is a central government that owns all the means of production, decides on the distribution of goods, and makes plans for the economy. This is why a transition from capitalism to socialism is much easier than jumping straight to communism.

In fact, socialism is considered the first step toward communism in the Marxist theory. Only when the levels of production are high enough, can the next step be taken. In order for communism to be a success, everyone needs to understand that they’re working not because they have to, but because they want to benefit society as a whole.

In a communistic society, there’s no private property: everything is common and can be used by the individual who needs it the most at the moment. When it comes to socialism, however, there’s personal and public property. Personal property, e.g. houses and clothes, is owned by the individual. Factories, means of production, and other public properties are owned by the government.

One more difference is that communism rejects all religions, while socialism gives the individual the freedom to choose whatever he wants to believe in. Still, socialism generally promotes the separation of state and religious beliefs.

Finally, communism is a political system, while socialism is primarily economic and can coexist with a variety of political systems. The biggest similarity between the two is that none of the systems has proved to be successful in practice. Despite the fact that they sound almost as if they’re able to create heaven on earth, people want to become rich, have more private properties, and have power. As long as this human nature doesn’t change, neither socialism nor communism will ever work.

Here’s a simple table summarizing these points:

Aspect Socialism Communism
Ownership Collective ownership of production State ownership of production
Distribution According to individual contribution According to the needs of each individual
Government Transitional stage toward communism No need for a government
Class system Aim to eliminate class distinctions Aim to abolish all class distinctions
Economy Mixed economy with some private ownership Centralized planned economy

Socialism vs. Communism Examples

Socialism Examples

  • The book provided an analysis of socialism as an economic system that aims to distribute resources more equitably.
  • Critics of socialism often argue that it can lead to decreased incentives for individual entrepreneurship and innovation.
  • Supporters of socialism believe that it can lead to a fairer society by reducing income inequality.
  • The debate about socialism versus capitalism is a central theme in many political discussions around the world.
  • Socialism has been implemented in various forms in different countries, with varying degrees of success.
  • The professor explained that socialism involves state ownership or control of key industries and services.

Communism Examples

  • The documentary explored the history of communism in Eastern Europe during the 20th century.
  • Communism as a political ideology advocates for a classless society where all property is publicly owned.
  • During the Cold War, the United States and its allies were engaged in a struggle against the spread of communism.
  • The book described the utopian ideals of communism, where everyone would work according to their ability and receive according to their needs.
  • He studied the effects of communism on economic development and individual freedoms in various countries.
  • The fall of the Berlin Wall was a significant event in the decline of communism in Europe.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the core differences between socialism and communism?
In socialism, we advocate for social ownership of the means of production and democratic control, but individuals can still own personal property. In communism, the state owns all property and resources, aiming to distribute them according to need, with the eventual goal of a stateless, classless society.

How do compensation and work vary between the two systems?
Under socialism, we can see compensation tied to one’s contribution to the economy, allowing for wages and personal accumulation. In communism, however, the philosophy is “from each according to his ability, to each according to his needs,” where work is done for the collective benefit without direct compensation related to individual output.

Do socialism and communism view democracy differently?
Yes, they do. In our view, socialism is compatible with democratic institutions and is often characterized by active democratic participation in both the political and economic spheres. Communism, however, has historically been associated with less democratic or even authoritarian regimes, although in theory, it aims for a classless, stateless society where decisions are made on a communal basis.

Is private ownership completely eliminated in both systems?
Not entirely. We see socialism allowing for some level of private ownership, particularly of personal assets and small businesses, as long as the major industries are publicly owned. In contrast, communism seeks to eliminate private ownership to prevent any class-based distinctions.

Last Updated on December 8, 2023

7 thoughts on “Socialism vs. Communism: Differences between Communism vs. Socialism”

  1. It’s a controversial subject. Everybody has different definitions.

    My definitions have been that Socialism is pretty close to this description. Everybody throws their money into a pot, in proportion to their income. Then, things that the society needs, as a whole, get paid for out of that. So, roads and bridges, courts and police and jails, government, military: those are all socialist systems. Most westernized countries have a big chunk of socialism, despite what conservatives say.

    Communism is Socialism with Authoritarianism (my definition). It’s the authoritarianism that makes it bad. Lenin had to invoke authoritarianism because the absolute socialism (roughly what this article calls ‘commuism’) wasn’t working, so you had to do that “for their own good”.

    Early communists like Marx and Lenin were incredibly arrogant. They were like, “Of Course the people want communism! Even if they think they don’t. They’ll be glad once they get used to it. After all, Communism is the system of the future! After a few decades, ALL countries will be communist; the people will demand it!”

    That unwillingness to pay attention to reality, and make changes based on experience was one of the biggest reasons Communism was such a disaster. (In addition to all the other reasons…)

    Reply

Leave a Comment